Toward a sound awakening: by Yusuf al-Qaradawi(View All Articles by: Yusuf al-Qaradawi) |
|
|
Table of Content:
- Forward
- Introduction
- Chapter 1: The correction of concepts
-
The renovation of religion in light of the Prophet's tradition
- A Muslim is required to work always for both his religious and worldly matters
- Discussion and Preponderance
- When does renovation take place?
- Whom is the renovation for?
- What is the renovated religion?
- The Meaning of Renovation
- Innovation of faith
- The importance of faith in our life
- Our need for a faith-based education
- Innovative Research and Renovation - In the midst of legislative orders and modern necessities
- Islam and Evolution - Is evolution becoming Islamic or is Islam evolving
- The status of man in Islam
-
The renovation of religion in light of the Prophet's tradition
- Chapter 2: A Dialogue on Some Intelectual Issues Concerning the Alien Trends
- Chapter 3: Between the Reasons of Hope and the Factors of Despair
- Chapter 4: What is it We Need
FOREWORD
One of the distinct features of the current reality of the Muslim Ummah is the dynamic resurgence that it is experiencing, today, after crossing the dark eras of stagnation and loss, in which it was prey to the overriding forces of covetousness. Not only did these forces seek to blot out the Ummah's identity, but they also strove to undermine its faith and sow the seeds of despair in the hearts of Muslims, insidiously propagating the idea that modern life was in diametric contradiction to faith, and that to think about their conciliation was pure wishful thinking. An array of misconceptions were thus concocted and widely circulated through the cultural institutions of these evil forces. To this end, a powerful arsenal of means was harnessed, so much so that they virtually succeeded in turning fallacy into taken-for-granted fact, aided in this by the lack of an objective awareness about the Islamic truths and the failure to publicize the Islamic teachings.
Introduction
Plentiful, noble and blessed gratitude to Allah, enough gratitude to fill the heavens and the earth, and whatever else that is unattainable but that God Wills. His prayers and greetings on the best of his creations and the last of his messengers, Sayyiduna Mohammed, as well as his relatives and disciples and those who follow them in goodness until the day of reckoning.
These are papers and articles, which were written at different
and distant times and were published in different journals (Among these, there
are some which were written and published over thirty years ago and some which
were published this year.
Some of them were published in Cairo in the following journals Mimbar Al Islam,
Nour Al Islam, Al Azhar. Some of them were published in Beirut in the
joun1als,Al Mujtama' and Al Shihab. Others were published in Qatar in Al Doha,
Al 'Ummah, Al Haqq. Finally, there are some others which were published in Al
Ba?th Al Islamii, which is published by the Conference of Muslim Scholars.)
I still recollect that some of these articles
were published immediately after I was released from the War Prison in 1956 in
the Journal Mimbar Al Islam, which was published by the Section of
Religious Affairs at the Wakf Ministry in Egypt.
I used to sign these articles under the name of Yusuf Abdullah for fear that the
name Al Qardawi would raise the opposition of the investigating services, which
purposely set up hindrances in the face of all public action that I wanted to
undertake and address to the population at the time. This was the same situation
in both the domains of education and religious and spiritual guidance, which
were the only two domains open to me, and which correspond to my training and
speciality.
It also happened that I applied for a teaching position at the Institutes of Al
Azhar. My name was the first on the list of those who were admitted and the
total of my marks was the highest of all the applicants from the three schools
of Al Azhar: The School of the Foundations of Islam, The School of
Jurisprudence, The School of the Arabic Language. When the names were submitted
to the investigating services, my name was dropped.
That is why I used to use a name other than my real one to sign my articles, so
that I would not be discovered by the spying agents.
The following is one among the anecdotes which I still recall in this respect. In the Section of Religious Affairs in the Wakf there was an administrator by the name of Yusuf Abdullah. When my first article entitled "A wish by Omar" was published under the name of Yusuf Abdullah, the administrator in question thought that one of the scholars, such as Professor Al Ghazali or Professor Sayed Sabiq wrote the article and signed it in his name, so that he can benefit from it and draw the special grant for this article for himself. He actually went immediately to claim the grant and was about to receive it when a colleague of his, who was aware of the secret, informed him of the actual author of the article. That is how I was about to lose the five pound grant, which was for me at the time a big fortune.
I am not quite sure why such thoughts have
crossed my mind, as I am writing these lines. But this tale may have within its
folds a lesson and a reminder to myself and to people in general. God Almighty
has ordered us to recall the miseries of the past and to compare them to the
benefits of the present, to mention the blessings of Allah and His Favours and
to Thank Him for what He has Granted us.
This is how God Almighty reminded His Messenger, Peace Be Upon Him (PBUH), and
all the Muslims who were with him in Al Madina of the way they were in Mecca, so
He Said: (And remember, when ye were few and reckoned feeble in the
land, and were in fear lest men should extirpate you, how He gave you refuge,
and strengthened you with His help, and made provisions of good things for you,
that haply ye might be thankful) (Surah 8, Verse 26)
The importance of this introduction resides in the fact that these words flow from the same source, that of Islam, in spite of the difference in the times, places and the conditions in which they were written. This religion which is whole but balanced, and which is strong but does not weaken the wishful person who does not despair. This religion is also that of the warrior who does not give up his arm. The source that we mentioned was erupted by the concerns of the Muslims, which become bigger, wider and deeper by the day. Be they new or old, they all flow in the same bed and aspire to the same aim: That of contributing to the achievement of a true and authentic Islamic awakening, which is characterised by rationality, maturity and enlightenment. This awakening should be that of intelligent minds, clean hearts and young resolutions. It should be well aware of its aims and means, its rights and responsibilities, and of who is its friend and who is its foe.
This awakening should aim at renovating the
religion and promoting life. It should correct the misconceptions and should
straighten the crooked paths, awaken the sleeping minds, stir the still lives,
inject some soul in the still bodies and should re-instil in them, movement and
development.
Nowadays, thanks to Allah Almighty, we see signs of this awakening that were not
apparent to many in the past.
We also thank Allah Almighty for the fact that the contribution of the scholars,
the sacrifice of the martyrs, the words of the advocates, the efforts of the
reformers, the hard work of the renovators did not all go in vain. These efforts
were not, as some thought, a cry in a valley or a blow in ashes. They gave their
fruit at the right time, by the will of God.
Allah Almighty certainly spoke the truth when He said: (Seest though not how Allah coineth a similitude: A goodly saying, as a goodly tree, its root set firm, its branches reaching into heaven, giving its fruit at every season by permission of its Lord ? Allah coineth the similitudes for mankind in order that they may reflect)(Surah 14, Verses 24-25).
I ask Allah Almighty, the Generous, Whose Favours are Great, Who has made the present day of this awakening better than its yesterday, to make its tomorrow better than its today. May God accept and approve.
(Our Lord! Accept from us (this duty). Lo! Thou, only Thou, art the Hearer, the Knower)(Surah 2,Verse 127).
Dr. Yusuf Al Qardawi
The renovation of religion in light of the Prophet's tradition
Abu Hurayrah, God Bless Him (GBH), relates that the Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said: (Once every hundred years, Allah sends to this nation a man to renovate its religion.) (.This Hadith was quoted in Abu Dawud's Sunan under number 4270 in Al Haakim's Mustadrak, in Al Fitan (4: 522), in Al Bayhaqii's Ma'rifat Al Sunan wai 'Aathaar (p. 52) in Al Khatiib's TaarIikh Baghdad (2: 61). It was also quoted in Al 'Albaanii's collection A1 Sahilha (No. 599) and was also ascribed to Abu 'Amr Al Daani in Al Fitan [ and also in SahIih Al Jaami' Assaghiir, 1874, Second Edition, Al Maktab Al 'Islaamii.] It was also quoted in Al Harawi's Thamm 'al Kalaam, and in Sheikh Muhammad Zakariya Ben Yahya Al Kandahlawi's comment upon Badl Al Majhuud fii Hall Abi Dawud which attributed to Mawlana Abdulhay the claim that the Hadith was also quoted in Al Hasan Bin Sufyan's Musnad and in Al Bazzaz and Tabaraani's Awsat and in Abu Na'im's Al Hilya ... and also elsewhere). This Hadith was quoted by Abu Dawud at the beginning of The Book of Malaahim, in the chapter treating the issue of what is usually stated about the beginning of each century (He said in Badl Al Majhund V.17/ 201, " that is that one hundred years is a century during which events take place and at the end of which He Sends the renovator.)
The authentication of the Hadith is as follows: Suleyman Ben Dawud A1 Mahri informed us that Ibn Wahab said: "I was informed by Sa'id Ben Abi Ayyub on the basis of a quote by Sharahiil Ben Yazid A1 Ma'afiri quoting Abu 'Alqamah reporting that Abu Hurayrah, as far as my knowledge permits, said , that the Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said "Once every hundred years, the end of the Hadith".
Abu Dawud reports that Abdul Rahman Ben Shurayh A1 'Iskandaraani quoted the Hadith without going past Sharaahiil, i.e. he did not mention anybody beyond him.
In Mukhtasar Al Sunan (Number 4123), Al Mundarii states :"Abdul Rahman Bin Shariih A1 'Iskandaraani is trustful, Al Bukhari and Muslim agree on the authenticity of his Hadith in spite of the fact that he abridged it (Al Mundarii's Mukhtasar Al Sunan V.6/163, publication of the Maktaba Athariya in Lahore, Pakistan, based on the edition of Al Sunnah Al Muhammadia in Egypt, authenticated by Muhammad Haamid A1 Faqiih.); i.e. he dropped two of the referees from his authentication: Abu 'Alqamah and Abu Hurayrah. The problematic Hadith is the one whose authentication is missing two of the referees Hadith is the one whose authentication is missing two of the referees who are mentioned one after the other elsewhere.
The fact that Abu Dawud raises this point does not falsify the Hadith. Even if Abdul Rahman abridged it, we should also mention that Sa'id Bin Ayyub summarised it and authenticated it. This is further authentication as it is explicitly stated in the sources of the Hadiths.
The authentication of the Hadith is correct and the men who have authenticated it are trustworthy, they are Muslim's disciples. Many people have authenticated it, and even Al Suyuutii alluded to its authenticity in Al Jaami' Al Saghiir. It was confirmed by the scholar Al Manaawii (See Fayd 'Al Qadiir Sharh 'Al Jaami' Al Saghiir V.2/282), who commented and explained it and mentioned that Al Haakim corrected it (It is not in Al Mustadrak that he authenticated it, he actually overlooked it. Al Albaanii said: it may be that it was unintentionally omitted from the published version of Al Mustadrak, see the collection of articles Al Sahiiha, V.2 p. 15], article number 599, published by Al Nlaktab Al Islaamli, Beirut. ). He said, "Al Ziin Al 'Iraqi and others have said that its reference is correct and it was quoted in Sheikh Al Albaanii in his collection of authentic Hadiths (No. 559).
A further comment on the content of the Hadith
This noble Hadith is made up of a single declarative sentence, which contains one piece of information about the unseen, and given by the one who does not speak vainly. He knows of the unseen only what Allah Almighty taught him, as stated in the following Quranic verse: ((He is) the Knower of the Unseen and He Revealeth unto none His secret, save unto every messenger whom He Hath Chosen') (Surah 72, Verses 26-27)
Abu Dawud quoted it in the book of "Malaahim" in his Sunan. The Arabic word "malaahim" is the plural of "malhamah", which means: the battles which will occur in future between the Muslims and their enemies. This notion is taken from the close contact of the two opposing armies, as was the case in what was predicted by the Prophet (PBUH) in terms of the battles between Muslims and Turks, Romans, Jews and others.
Some of what was predicted by the Prophet (PBUH) has actually happened, the rest is still in the realm of the unseen. We are certain that it will take place at the moment when Allah wills it. Muhammad (PBUH) has never lied and was never mistrusted.
The topic of these fierce battles is usually mentioned in the context of two other topics: trials and the signs of the day of reckoning. It may include both of them as the two may be distinguished one from the other. But they all refer to the future and all the events that Allah may hold within it.
The truth is that such topics as the trials, fierce battles, signs of the day of reckoning are among the topics which the most enlightened scholars have to research more thoroughly. They should not leave them to hastier individuals who shy away from these topics by denying their existence totally, or to others who believe everything that is said about such topics without due consideration, or even to others who misinterpret them.
The aim of the Hadith
The aim of this Hadith is to fill the hearts of Muslims with the hope that their flame will never go out and that their religion will never die. It also ensures them that Allah Almighty provides them regularly, i.e. once a century, with the person who brings youth and life back to Islam.
Once a century does not mean precisely the hundredth year or the hundredth and one of the century, but the end of the century or the beginning of the following century. This is the actual meaning of "Once every hundred years, in the Hadith. In reality, we cannot decide when this is; whether it is one hundred years after the Prophet's Hijra, or death or resurrection as we will show below.
What is important is that Allah does not leave this Ummah without providing it with someone to awaken it from its sleep and to gather its dispersion.
We absolutely need to emphasise this meaning, in order to fight the wave of despair whose tide has risen. We need to fight the feeling that there is neither use nor hope, and that Islam is receding and that unbelief is on the rise. We also need to fight the feeling that the minor signs of the day of reckoning have already appeared, and that the situation will remain as such until the major signs are with us and the day of reckoning will arise on the people who do not say "Allah! Allah!" as stated in Al Sahiih (.This was cited in Muslim quoting Anas "Doomsday only comes when people on earth stop uttering Allah, Allah", Hadith number 234, authenticated by Muhammad Fu'ad Abdulbaqi.).
There are people who confirm this meaning by other Hadiths, which they construe differently from what the Hadiths mean. The following Hadith is one that has been used thusly : (Islam started in loneliness, and will end as it started in loneliness, blessed be the lonely) (Muslim quoted this from Abu Hurayra's Hadith number 232; Al Tirmidi quoted it from Ibn Mas'ud's Hadith number 2631 and said: "Good, correct, lonely". This Hadith is numbered 3986 by Ibn Maajah. Al Jaami' Al Saghlir refers to Ibn Majah on a quote of Anas and Al Tabaraani, themselves quoting Salmaan, Sahl Ibn Sa'd and Ibn 'Abbes. Al Bukhaari did not quote it, but Al Tarmidi states in Al'ilal that he asked Al Bukhari about it and he said: " It's a good Hadith (Al Fayd 2/223).).
These people seem to have omitted that the loneliness of Islam does not at all mean its weakness. The same applies to the loneliness of those who believe in it and who defend it. It does not mean their weaknesotheir insignificance. It means that they are uniquely distinguished and that their personality has not dissolved in others, actually they are the pride of their people.
In some versions of this Hadith, the Prophet (PBUH) described the lonely in the following manner: (those who repair what others have abused in my tradition) (. This was quoted by Al Tirmidi as number 2632 in the Hadith of Kuthair Ben Abdullah Ben 'Amr Bin 'Awf Al Huznii, but it is a weak one, in spite of the fact that Al Tarmidi claims that it is a good Hadith, he even sometimes authenticates it. In Al Masnad the Hadith of Abdullah Ben 'Amr: " Blessed be the lonely! Blessed be the lonely!" is traceable Then, it was said: " Who are the lonely, oh Messenger of Allah?" Then, he said: " Good people in the midst of people of evil, of whom there are more who disobey than those who give". (Hadith number 7072, of which Sheikh Shaker says: its reference is correct). These lonely people are neither desperate nor negative in their societies, but rather, they repair what others have abused in terms of the traditions of Islam, and revive its good behaviour and morality, which had declined.
There is nothing in the Hadith that indicates that the loneliness is general, comprehensive and lasting. As it was mentioned by Ibn Al Qayyim (See Madaarij Al Saalikiin by Ibn Al Qayyim, Vol. 3 p.l92, as by Mohammad Haamid Al Faqih), this may happen in one country but not the other, to one people but not the other, in one time but not the other. Then the conditions change, and the weak become strong and the defeated become victorious. In this respect, the following Hadith of Anas's cited in A1 Bukhari is often quoted: "The era you are living in is always better than the era that will follow'' (This Hadith was quoted by Al Bukhari in Kituab Al Fitan on the basis of a statement of A1 Zoubeir Ibn Addi. He said: "We went to Anas Ben Maalik's and we complained to him about how people were being mistreated by Al Hajjaj (i.e. Ai Hajjaj Ben Yussef Al Thaqafiy), so he said: "Be patient, because the era you are living in is always better than the era that will follow, until you meet your God. I heard this trom your Prophet (PBUH). "This is Hadith number 7068 in Al Bukhari's Al Fath, Vol. 3, pp. 19-20, published by Dar Al Salafia under the management of Al Sheikh Abulaziz Ben Baz, the numbering was done by Muhammad Fu'ad Abdul Baqi, and the edition was supervised by Mr. Muhibb Al Diin Al Khatlib.).
This Hadith should not be taken literally or in its absoluteness and generality. Some scholars have uncovered a positive interpretation of this Hadith, and this was mentioned by Hafidh Ibn Hajar in his interpretation. He said: "The Hadith refers to the Prophet's companions who heard it, in spite of the fact that Anas, God Bless him, understood that it was addressed to people in general'' (Al Fath, Vol. 13 p. 21 in which he said: "Ibn Hibban claimed in his Sahiih that Anas's Hadith is not the same, as it is the case in general, as the Hadiths quoted by Al Mahdi. It fills the earth with justice after it had been filled with injustice.). This means that the Prophet (PBUH) wanted this Hadith to advise the group of followers who heard it, in order for them to be prepared for the changes yet to come after the time of the Prophet. So neither should the conditions they will experience after him, nor the tremendous changes they will see afterwards discourage them or shake their belief in their religion and their path.
Without this understanding of the contradiction between the Hadith and reality, one would not understand why the time of Omar Ben Abdulaziz was better than the time of the Ummeyyads before him.
The same can be said about the time of Noor Al Diin Mahmuud "2">(His name is Mahmuud teen Zanki (Imaad Addiin) alias (the Just King): He was the King of Syria, the Arabic Peninsula and Egypt. He is the most just, noble and gentle king of his time. His biography is characterised by his justice, goodness and his endeavour to establish God's Law within the land, and to fight the enemies of Allah outside it. His behaviour was similar to that of the Rightly Guided Caliphs. He fought the crusaders, and was victorious in his battles. He built schools and mosques and caravanserais ori the roads. He was the first one to build a conference house. He liked scholarly work and scholars. He honored them and was generous with them. He stood to greet them and did not refuse their requests. He was knowledgeable of jurisprudence according to the rite of Abu Hanifa, without fanaticism. He attended lectures in Aleppo and Damascus. He died in 569 H. See Al Aa'lam by Azzarkalii, Vol. 8/46; Al Rawdatayn by Abu Shama; Ibn Al Athiir, Vol. 11/151, Al Biduaya wannihanya, Vol. 12/ 277-284, published in Beirut. See also Noor Addiin Mahmund: The Biography of a true fighter, published by Addar Assa'uudlya linnashr wa ttawzli', Jeddah 1404 H / 1984 AD.), the Martyr and Salaah Al Diin A1 Ayyubi (. His name is Abu Al Muthaffar Yusuf Ben Ayub Ben Shaadii Alias The Victorious King, he is one of the most famous Muslim kings, and the keenest on improving his country and on being just to the people. He defeated the crusaders, and it was through him that God Almighty liberated Jerusalem, after it had been occupied by them for more than ninety years. He also Made him victorious in the famous battle of Hittin. He governed Egypt and Syria and founded the Ayyubite dynasties. He saved for himself neither money nor realty, except for the schools and hospitals that he built. He died in 589 H. See Wafayaut Al 'A'yaan by Ibn Khillikaan, Vol. 2/376; Ibn Al Athiir, Vol. 12/37; Al Biduaya wa nnihaaya, Vol. 13/2 and following, as well as the end of Vol. 12. See also Shadharuat Adhdhahab, Vol. 2/298 and Al Aa'lam by Azzarkalli, Vol. 9/291-293.). It is on the hands of these two men that Allah liberated the land of Islam from the grasp of the crusaders, revived the Prophet's tradition and annihilated blasphemy. The time of these two men was better than that of those who lived before them.
In the same vein, if the Hadith had been taken at its face value, as many people understand it, it would be in contradiction with the Hadiths that referred to the emergence of Islam, and its appearance before the day of reckoning especially at the time of the appearance of that Caliph, or the righteous prince who fills the land with justice in place of the injustice and tyranny that it had been undergoing. This Caliph is the one who has come to be known as the Mahdi (.A number of Hadiths refering to this subject have been quoted in the Sunan, but no explicit mention of it was made in the two versions of the Sahih.). The same contradiction would apply also to the time when Jesus Christ, son of Mary, came to spread Islam, and not accept any other religion in its place (See Attasrlih bimaa tawaatara fii nuzunli Imasiih by the scholar Anouar Al Kashmiiri, and authenticated by Abdulfattah Abu Ghuddah.).
I do not know why such kinds of Hadiths do spread, while other Hadiths which bring hope and good news to the Muslims are concealed. This is the case of the following Hadith by Ahmed and Attirmidii: (The case of my Ummah is like that of rain, one knows not which is better, its beginning or its end) (. This Hadith was quoted by Attirmidi, who was quoting Anas, under number 2873, as he said: "This Hadith is good but is not known. In Al Jaami' Assaghilr Assuyuutii attributed it to Ahmed, who was also quoting Anas, to Ahmed, who was quoting 'Ammaar Bin Yaassir, to Abu Ya'laa on the basis of a reference to Ali, to Attabaraanii quoting Abdallah Bin 'Amr. In Al Fath Ibou Hajar said: " This is a good Hadith, there are ways which could make it closer to authenticity. Al Manaawii says:" Ibn Hibbaan authenticated it on the basis of 'Ammaar's Hadith (See Fayd Al Qadiir, Vol. 5/507).).
This is also the case of a Hadith quoted by Ahmed, Ibn Hibbaan and Al Haakim: (Announce this Ummah the good news of sublimity, piety, nobility, victory and control over the land.)... In Al Jaami' Al Saghilr he attributed it to Ahmed, to Ibn Hibbaan and to Al Haakim as we]l to Al Bayhaqi in Ashsha'b, quoting his father. A1 Manaawii mentions in Al Fayd (Vol. 3/ 201) that Al Haythamii said on the basis of an attribution by Ahmed: Its men are the men of authentic Hadiths, although Al Hakiim corrected it and Adhdhahbii agreed with him in one part of the correction and disagreed in another. And this is correct if we take two different references in consideration. On the basis of the reference cited by Al Haakim in Al Moustadrak (Vol. 4/31 ] ) Adhdhahbii agreed with the correction, but he commented on it in (4/318). See also our comment on Hadith number ]5 in our book entitled Al Mountaqaa Min Attarghiib wa ttarhiib. Al Mundhirii mentioned it in Attarghiib and he mentioned Al Haakim's correction of it and confirmed it. A] Albaanii also mentioned it in Sahilh Al Jaami'2825).
The same can also be said of the Hadith quoted by Ahmed and Ibn Hibbaan: (That this matter (meaning this religion) reaches what night and day have reached and that God Wil1 leave behind neither the house of Madar nor that of Wabar without introducing Islam to it be it with honour or with disgrace, the first honouring Islam, and the second disgracing unbelief)( It was quoted by Ibn Hibbaan in his Sahiih (1631, ]632). Al Albaanii also mentioned it in Al Sahiiha under number 3.).
As to the appearance of minor signs of the approaching of the day of reckoning, it does not mean that the page of Islam has been turned, and that the day of reckoning is coming tomorrow or the day after. The coming of the Prophet (PBUH) is a minor sign of the day of reckoning. In the Sahih the Prophet is quoted as saying: (I and the day of reckoning came together like these two)(. This was cited by Ahmed, Al Sheikhaan and Attirmidhii quoting Anas, Ahmed and Al Sheikhaan also attributed it to Sahl Ben Sa'd. It has also been attributed to Jaaber, Bureydah and others. Al Haafidh Assuyuutii said: " all these references concur " (Al Fayd,Vol. 3/202). See also Allu'lu' almarjaan fiimaa ttafaqa 'alaihi shsheykhaan by Mohammad Futaad 'abd Albaaqii, ed. By'Iissaa Alhalabii, Hadith number 1862, 1863. ) and he indicated his index and middle finger.
A Muslim is required to work always for both his religious and worldly matters.
The Muslim is required to work for his living and to be productive and creative, until the very end of his life. He should not procrastinate in the working of the land, and this is what Allah's Messenger (PBUH) taught us when he said: (If the world is about to end and one of you has a palm tree plant in his hand, he should plant it before he dies, if he can).
Why should he plant it if the world is about to end? Why should he plant it if he is not going to live till he can pick its fruit? There is not even somebody who is going to live after him so that he can say:" People before us planted so that we can eat, and we are planting to provide those after us with food," because when the world ends it ends for everybody. The idea here is to glorify work for the sake of work and to keep the Muslim productive and creative until the last moment of his life, and as long as he is able to work.
If this is required for man's worldly matters
how could it be possible that the same would not be asked of his religious
activity? How can religion be lower in priority than worldly matters?
The Muslim is required to observe the commands of his religion as much as he
can. He should advise people to do good deeds and to be charitable and to avoid
committing evil deeds. They should fight for the cause of Allah, and against
evil and decadence. They should also collaborate with their brother Muslims in
doing good and worshipping Allah. The texts which have come with all these
commands have not been abolished, and are not specific to a particular time.
They are permanent and will be there until Allah inherits the land and its
inhabitants.
A further look at the Hadith
We have to show what is meant by renovate in the Hadith and who is the renovator, and what is a renovated religion, who it is renovated for, what is the meaning of renovation, what is its extent and what are all its aspects?
Who undertakes the renovation?
As to who undertakes the renovation and the revival, it is dependent upon the
clarification of the sense of the word "who" in the Hadith. Many people have
understood this to be in the singular and considered that the renovator is no
more than one individual from amongst the geniuses and extraordinary people of
the Ummah, who is sent by the care of Allah to renovate what has become old, to
strengthen what has become weak and to mend what has become torn.
On the basis of this, they mentioned a number of individual renovators. Thus the renovator of the first century is the fifth of the guiding Caliphs Omar Ben Abdulaziz (d. 101 H). The renovator of the second century is Mohammad Ben Idriis Ashshaafi'ii (d. 204 H). There is disagreement over the renovator of the third century, as there were many outstanding people during that century. Amongst those who were mentioned, we have Abulhassan Al Ash'arii (d. 324 H), Abul'abbas Ben Surayj (d. 306 H), and Annasaa'ii the author of Assunan (d.303 H). For the fourth century, they mentioned Judge Abubakr Albaaqillaanii (d. 403 H) and Abuhaamid Al'isfaraayiinii (d. 406 H). For the fifth century they mentioned Abuhaamid Alghazaalii (d. 505 H), and for the sixth Alfakhr Arraazii (d. 606 H) as well as Arraafi'ii (d. 623 H). For the seventh century Ibn Daqiiq Al 'id (d. 703) was mentioned and for the eighth we have Al Haafidh Zinaddiin Al'iraaqii (d. 808 H) or Siraajaddiin Albulqainii (d. 805 H).
Al Haafidh Jalaaladdin Assayuutii (d. 891H) wrote a poem in relation to this and included in it the names of the renovators up to his time, and aspired to be nominated the renovator of the ninth century, as he claimed himself to be an absolute innovator, but his contemporaries denied him this honour.
This poem was quoted in Fayd Alqadiir by the scholar Al Manaawii as follows:
Thanks to God Almighty the Generous
The Provider favours to the followers of the Prophet's tradition
We request His Blessing and Peace
Upon a Prophet whose religion does not obliterate.
It was heralded in outstanding news
Which was reported by every valuable scholar
That at the beginning of each century
God Almighty sends gracefully to the religion of this Ummah
A creative scholar to renovate
The religion of the right path because he is a renovator
For the first century there was Omar,
The just Caliph by consensus and certainty
Ashshafi'ii was the renovator of the second century
As he was knowledgeable in the noble sciences
Ibn Surayj was the third leader
But Al Ash'arii was considered the third renovator by his followers.
Al Baaqillaanii was the fourth, or was it Sahl or
Al' Isfaraayiinii, a difference of opinion was related
And the fifth learned renovator is 'AI Ghazaali
Whose rank is unquestionable
The sixth man to be proud of is Imam'Arraazii
And 'Arraafi'ii is like him in ranking
And the seventh is he who rose to high standings
Ibn Daqiiq 'Al'id upon whom there is total agreement
The eighth learned man is 'Albalqiinii, or Zineddin, the preserver of the people,
But the condition is that the man should be alive amongst
His people as the century changes
He should be known for his knowledge
And he should defend the Prophet's tradition in his discourse
He should be versed in all fields of knowledge
And his science should spread to all his contemporaries
He should be saturated with the Hadiths
And should be one of the Prophet's people and should be strong
The renovator is known to be one
This was testified by the Hadith and all the scholars
The ninth century is now upon us
And the Right Guide (meaning the Prophet.)
does not fail to keep his promises
And I have prayed to be the renovator of this century
And the favours of Allah are not denied (Fayd Al QadiIr, Vol. 2 p. 282).
While Assuyuutii has considered that the
renovator is an individual, who is famous amongst his people, 'Almanaawii has
repeated what 'Alhaafidh Adhdhahbii had said: Who, stands here for the plural,
not the singular. Thus we say for example that at the end of the third century
there was Ibn Surayj in jurisprudence, 'Al'ash'arii in the foundations, and 'Annasaa'ii
in Hadith. For instance, at the end of the sixth century there was 'Alfakhr
Arraazii in theology, 'Alhaafidh Abdulghani in Hadith, etc.
Ibn Al Athiir said in Jaami' 'Al'usuul: Many have contributed to the
interpretation of this Hadith, but each one has mentioned the leader who belongs
in his own rite, and attributed the Hadith to him. The better interpretation is
the one which is more general. Who may refer to the singular and the plural, and
does not refer exclusively to the religious scholars. The welfare of the 'Ummah
may come from its statesmen, the Hadith scholars, the Qur'an readers, the
preachers, etc. But the messenger must be mentioned in all fields of knowledge.
Thus, at the end of the first century, the
statesman was Omar Ben Abdulaziz, and among the scholars there were Muhammad 'Albaaqir,
Alqaasim Ben Muhammad, Saalim Ben Abdullah, Alhassan, Ibn Siiriin and others; as
to the readers there was Ibn Kathiir and for the Hadith there was Azzuhrii.
At the end of the second century, the statesman was Almaamuun; for the scholars
there were Ashshaafi'ii and 'Allu'lu'ii from Abu Haniifa's rite, 'Ashhab from
Maalik's. As to the readers there was 'Alhadramii, for the Hadith there was Ibn
Ma'iin, and for the ascetics there was AL Karkhii.
At the end of the third century, the statesman was Almuqtadir. The scholars were
Ibn Surayj Ashshaafi'ii, Attahaawii Alhanafii and Alkhallaal Alhanbalii, the
theologian was Al Ash'arii and the Hadith scholar was Annassaa'ii.
At the end of the fourth century, the
statesman was Alqaadir. The scholars were Al'isfaraayiinii from the Shaafi'i
rite, Alkhawarizmii from the Hanafi's rite, Abulwahaab from the Maaliki's rite
and Alhussayn from the hanbali's rite (. His full name is Albussayn Ben Khalaf
Alfiraa'). The theologians were Albaaqillaani and Ibn Fowrk and the Hadith
scholars were Alhaakim, the ascetic was Annuurii; and so forth for the rest of
the centuries (. Ibn Athiir's Jaami' 'Al'usaul, vol. 11 pp. 320-324. It should
be noted that Ibn Athiir mentioned a few people whom he considered as
renovators, in spite of the fact that they haven't reached such a level as did
the Abbassid statesmen, and many reproaches can be made to them. The purpose
from reporting what he said is so that renovation does not become limited to a
single individual).
Al Haafidh also has mentioned in Al Fath, what others had pointed out elsewhere,
that it is not imperative that there be only one renovator at the end of each
century. The situation is like the one which Annawawii mentioned in the Hadith
:"There is still a group of people in my nation who defend the truth".
This means that it is possible that the group is composed of a variety of people from the Muslims, amongst whom there are the courageous people and war experts, a jurisprudence scholar, a Hadith scholar and interpreter, a statesman, a person who promotes good deeds and advises against evil deeds and an ascetic and a worshipper. It is not necessary for all of them to be in the same country, but it is possible for them to be in the same continent, or be located in several continents. They may also be located in the same country or that they be in some countries but not in others. It is also possible to evacuate the whole earth from some of them, one by one until there is only one group countries. When they all disappear the world ends.
Alhaafidh Ben Hajar said: "This is approved. The necessary set of features that need to be found in the renovator are not specific to a particular kind of good-deeds, and it is not necessary either that all characteristics of good-doing should gather in a single individual, except if that is attributed to Omar Ben Abdulaziz. He was considered the renovator in the first century because he was a statesman and had all the characteristics of a righteous man and excelled in that. It is on this basis that Ahmed said that the Hadith which refers to renovators initially coincided perfectly with him. As to the ones after Omar, there is Ashshaafi'ii. In spite of having all the good characteristics and the pure attributes, he was not the statement in charge of the Holy War (Jihaad) and the application of justice. Alhaafidh also said: "On the basis of all this, anyone who has some of the required characteristics at the end of the century is a renovator, be they one or many"(. Fayd Al Qadiir, Vol. I p. 11. See also Fath Albari Vol. 12, p. 295, as well as Annawawi's Sharh of Mllslim Vol. 4 pp. 583-584, published by Ashsha b, Cairo).
Discussion and Preponderance
What I will advance here is that which was concluded by Ibn Al'athiir and Adhdhahbi and others, that Who in the Hadith under discussion, may indicate the plural as well as the singular. The reason for that is that Who in its original use refers to both. This is true in the Glorious Qur'an: "And whoso doeth good works, whether of male and female, and he (or she) is a believer, such will enter paradise (. Surah 4, Verse 124, and there are many other verses which confirm this.). If we assume this, then the renovator can be one individual, whom Allah sends for the purpose of rebirth and renovation, as was the case of Omar Ben Abdulaziiz. It has been said in this context that a person of high rank will revive a whole nation! A poet has said:
There is nobody who can deny that Allah
Can gather the world in one person
Renovation and revival can be undertaken by a group, or a school or a cultural, educational or ideological movement whose members all advocate good deeds and patience and collaborate in good deeds and piety. The task of renovation may be undertaken by different individuals or groups, each from his own position and points of interest and speciality. There may be one in the fields of intellect and science, others in the fields of behaviour and education, others in the fields of social work, government and politics, others in the fields of defence and resistance. Each one of these covers one of the fronts of Islam with united aims and principles, in spite of differences of positions and methods.
At this point, I would like to draw the attention of those who work for the cause of Islam, be they individuals or groups, to a matter that they need to be aware of: That there are differing methods governing work for the cause of Islam or that there are numerous groups endeavouring to renovate it, is neither an unhealthy phenomenon nor one that is unacceptable to Allah or to the Muslim believers, as long as the difference is one of diversity and speciality, not one of opposition and contradiction. In other words, complementarily, compatibility and co-operation must be the basic ingredient shared by the tasks of this undertaking, in such a way that each complements and supports the other. At the same time, they should all have the same stands toward important issues and vital attitudes in order to confront common enemies and stand in their face as one rank and as a solid structure.
As to the situation when each one of these
groups wants to establish itself and deny the others, or make the most important
issue that of establishing oneself on the efforts of others; it leads to the
weakening of all the Muslim potentials and their destruction from within. This
would also open up a gap for the common enemy to strike everybody at its own
ease and comfort.
The root 'ba'th' in the Hadith refers to: the securing of favourable motives,
the arrangement of appropriate conditions, the creation of the appropriate
climate for the emergence of the renovation of religion and the rebirth of the
nation according to the unchanging traditions established by Allah Almighty.
Then the meaning of 'ba'th' is not an
apparition of a renovator that is brought about by a universal miracle which
suddenly descends from the sky, or ascends from the earth instantly in order to
change the conditions of the people, if they have not been able to do it
themselves.
This is what we have understood from this Hadith and which corresponds to the
other Hadiths, which have linked the glorification of Islam during the recent
times to a group of people, and not a single individual, who advocate
righteousness, as in the well-known and authentic Hadith: "A group of our people
who advocate the word of Allah, will keep doing so and not be disturbed by
opposition, until the command of Allah reaches them ". This has been quoted by a
number of the Prophet's companions in approximately similar words (. See the
first issue of the journal called Al Markaz.).
The content of this Hadith is also similar to what we find in the following verse in which Allah Almighty says: "And of those whom We created there is a nation who guide with the Truth and establish justice therewith" (. Surah 7, Verse 181) It has also been stated that this verse is for "you", i.e. you the Muslims, and He Has Given people like you a similar verse (This was mentioned by Ibn Kathiir in his Tafsiir on the basis of a quote of Qutaadah, informing the Prophet (PBUH), Vol. 2 p. 269, printed by Al Halabi.).
This refers to Allah Almighty's word in the same Surah: (And of Mosest folk there is a community who lead with truth and establish justice therewith') (. Surah 7, Verse 159...).What the divine news have brought in these verses has been confirmed in this other Quranic verse: (And there may spring from you a nation who invite to goodness, and enjoin right conduct and forbid indecency. Such are they who are successful)( Surah 3, Verse 104). This is confirmed also in the following verse: "But help ye one another unto righteousness and pious duty"(33. Surah 5, Verse 2), and also in: "And exhort one another to truth and exhort one another to endurance" (. Surah 103, Verse 3.) and also: "Lo! Allah loveth those who battle for his cause in ranks, as if they were a solid structure"' (Surah 61, Verse 4.). This is also taken up in the Prophet's (PBUH): "God's hand is with united people" ( This has been quoted by'Attirmidii from the Hadith of Ibn Abbas no. 2167 and the Hadith of Ibn Omar no. 2168 and they both were surprised. This was also quoted by Attabaraanii on the basis of trustworthy references, as was stated by 'Al Haithamii. Ibn Hajar said: he has many quotes out of which many are precise and authenticated. As a result of al1 this, Assuyuutii pointed to its authenticity in his Al Jaami' Assaghiir. See Fayd Alqadilr, Vol.6/459. It was also quoted by Al Albaanii in Sahlih Al Jaami' under no. 8065, second printing.).
The truth, however, is that whatever gifts the individual may have, and whatever his productivity may be, he remains limited in his energy and his abilities, so long as he does not have collaborators who provide him with support and strength. Man remains limited and weak as long as he remains alone but as soon as he is surrounded by his friends, they provide him with company and strength. It is for this reason that Moses, the strong and upright Prophet, PBUH, said when God sent him as a messenger, (Appoint for me a henchman from my folk, Aaron my brother. Confirm my strength with him and let him share my task, that we may glorify Thee much and much remember Thee. Lo! Thou art ever Seeing us) (Surah 20, Verses 229-35). Allah Almighty said in His response: (We will strengthen shine arm with thy brother, and We will Give unto you both power),( Surah 28, Verse 35) This shows that however strong the individual may be he still needs the help of others in order to strengthen his defence. More eloquent and clearer what Allah Almighty said to His messenger (PBUH) "He it is Who supporteth thee with His help and with the believers, and (as for the believers) hath anuned their hearts' (Surah 8, Verses 62-63.).God has favoured him by backing him with his glory and by surrounding him with believers whose hearts are all set in the same direction, that of a unified conviction. In other words, he has given him support that resides in the fact that the group surrounding him are all solidary believers.
If we construe the Hadith in such a way, we no
longer need to expect an individual renovator who is sent to us from the heavens
like a present that we did not have to make any effort for. We would also no
longer need to imagine that for each century, we have to name one of the people
as the renovator of that century, with some people accepting him and others not.
This was the case of Al Jalaal Assuyuutii, (GBH), when he proclaimed himself the
renovator of the ninth century and had many of his contemporaries refute that.
We also no longer need an individual or a group to support one person or the
other to be the renovator for the tenth or the fourteenth century, and that
there is nobody that can equal him, with the result that his followers accept
him and the others reject him through sarcasm and ridicule.
We will not need that each group presents its candidate renovator, with the
Hadith specialists presenting one from them and the theologians doing the same.
We will not need either that the jurisprudence experts also present their own,
with each presenting one from their rite, the shafiites presenting a shafii and
the Hanbalis presenting a Hanbali Even the politicians used to promote a Caliph
or a prince as a candidate, and the ones involved with the defence of Islam
presenting an army chief as a candid.
With the kind of explanation we have githis Hadith, we involve the whole Ummah in the required renovation, and also in the selection, training and activity of the renovator. It also prepares the appropriate climate so that they can appear and be active. It also helps them achieve their aspirations, and remove the difficulties from their path. It supplies them with provisions and energy for their long journey towards what they hope to achieve. It is the nation which assigns each individual his task in the renovation program, so that he takes charge of it as it was said: you are guarding one of the fronts of Islam, so let no one cross it. In such a situation, the question that every Muslim will ask is: What is my role in the renovation program and what is my duty? Instead of wondering when the next renovator is going to appear.
When does renovation take place?
So when does renovation take place? The Hadith has set the time for renovation. It is the beginning of each hundred years, as the word 'ra's' in Arabic refers to the top of something and 'ra'su ssana' is the beginning of the year.
The interpreters have raised the issue of the beginning of the century. Al Manaawi said: "It refers to the Prophet's birthday, or the prophesy, the Hijra or death. He said: Even if it was said that it is the second, prophesy, which is closer to the meaning, this is possible. But, Assubkii and others state that it is the third (. Fayd Alqadiir, Vol. 1 p. 10), Hijra, that is the correct answer. Even in their discussion of the renovators they assumed the Hijra calendar as the basis, and that is reasonable. Because it is the calendar that Allah has inspired the Muslims to use since the time of Omar, and not any other. So they have not used the birth, or the resurrection or the death.
It is to be noted also that they have made it a rule that the death of the renovator may indicate the meaning of the beginning of the century, as is clarified by the death dates of those they had appointed as renovators. For example, Omar Ben Abdulaziz d. 101 H, Ashshaafi'ii d. 204 H, Ibn Surayj d.306 H, Albaakillaanii d. 403 H, A1 Ghazaalii d. 505 H, Arraazii d. 606 H, Ibn Daqiiq Al'id d.703 H and Al'iraaqii d. 808 H.
They have not mentioned such leaders as Ibn Taymiyya in spite of his great renovating movement in all aspects of the field of Islamic thought, because his death occurred much later than the beginning of the century, he died in 728 H.
The Hadith did not say that the renovator dies at the beginning of the century, but that Allah sends him at the beginning of the century. The meaning of this is that his duty starts at the beginning of the century, and not that it ends then. I have also noted that the scholar Almanaawii has drawn attention to this meaning when he wrote: "It should be realised that everybody who has interpreted the Hadith "God sends ..." and so forth to the end of the Hadith discusses this matter on the sole assumption that the renovator of a century is one who dies at the beginning of the century. And one should be aware that the meaning that should be drawn from the Hadith is that the appointment happens at the beginning of the century. The meaning of the appointment of the scholar refers to his competence to serve the people and his readiness to spread the wise thoughts. His death at the beginning of the century is a withdrawal not an appointment. Therefore, we should judge in fairness.
He continued: "And I know that Attayyibi said: "The selection of a renovator occurs when the century ends and there happens to be at the same time, a well-known and frequently-quoted scholar." Al Karmanii also said: "There used to be, before the end of a century, people who would start to preach and take charge of the matters of religious scholarship, but the meaning here is that of the scholar who is alive and well-known at the time the century ends". Almanaawii said: "There may be such a man during the century, who may even be better than the one who comes at the beginning of the century. The special mention of the beginning of the century is because it is usually a time of unsettlement for the scholars and that of the appearance of aberrations and the rise of charlatanism" (Fayd Alqadilr, Vol. 1 p. 12) This interpretation seems to be reasonable.
I think the Hadith actually refers to the idea that at the beginning of each century there is the beginning of a new era, new hope, and a rebirth.This allows the Muslim society to meet the new century with hearts that are full of hope for a bright future, and determination to achieve ideal actions and have truthful intentions to replace realities and make them coincide with what should be. One has to note here that what is expected of the Ummah is that at the beginning of each century it should take the time to account for what it has done and evaluate its achievements, so that it can learn from its past, improve its present, and look towards its future. It should supplicate its God that today be better for its people than yesterday and that tomorrow be better for them than today.
The Hadith did not deny the presence of renovators in the middle of centuries or at their end. As a matter of course, this is what happens quite usually if one reads the history of this Ummah. In this context, one should mention among other renovators: Ibn AljawzIi, Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn Alqayyim, Ashshantibii, Ibn Alwazlir, Ibn Hajar, Addahlawli, AshshawkaanIi and other eminent authorities.
Whom is the renovation for?
As for whom the renovation is intended, it is this Ummah, as the Hadith shows. It is for the followers of Mohammad, as Al Manaawii said. The original etymology of al Ummah is the group, grammatically singular but semantically plural. It may refer especially to the group to whom a Prophet was sent. On the basis of the fact that the Prophet emerged from them and that they invite people to Islam, they are called 'Ummat Adda'wah', 'the nation of Allah's message'. So if they, as a whole or only part of them, believe in what the Prophet brought to them, they are called the people who have responded, and that is the meaning here, the proof being in the fact that he mentions "its religion",- in the Hadith (Fayd Alqadiir, Vol. I p. 10).
The expression 'li haadhihi l'ummah' (for this nation) refers to the nation of Islam, the nation which has responded, along centuries and generations. As if the Prophet (PBUH) brings it in front of him and points to it when he says haadhihi l'ummah. This is the nation that is mentioned by God Almighty in His Glorious Qur'an: "Thus, We have appointed you a middle nation" (. Surah 2, Verse 143), "You are the best community that hath been raised up for mankind" . (Surah 3, Verse 110).
The Qur'an and the Prophet's Tradition mention no nation other than the Islamic nation, it is one whole nation in spite of differences in race colour and nationality. "Lo!, this your religion is one religion'"( Surah 21, Verse 92), " And Lo, this your religion is one religion and I am. your Lord, so keep your duty unto Me"( Surah 23, Verse 52.)We are not allowed to say the "Muslim
nations", because in Islam we do not have many nations, but one single nation,
but we may say "Islamic peoples" within this nation.
The absolute and complete renovation is that which covers the whole nation, and
affects it all, in the same way as the total renovation is what includes both
knowledge and action together. We have noticed this in such instances as that of
the influence of Omar Ben Abdulaziz, Ashshaafi'ii, Al Ghazzali and their likes
who have influenced the whole Muslim Nation, even though their influence may
have affected one or many aspects of Islamic life.
Renovation may also be partial, affecting only one of the aspects of life or one
country of the Islamic nation, or one single group and so forth, as it may
affect more than one aspect, or more than one group or more than one country.
What is the renovated religion?
The word "renovated" in the Hadith refers to the
noun "religion". Then what does the word religion mean in the Hadith? The use of
the word "religion", like that of the word "Islam", refers to one of two
matters:
First, the Divine way by which Allah Almighty sends His Prophet (PBUH) and to
reveal His Book, including the beliefs, the forms of worship and morality as
well as the jurisdiction to regulate the relationship of man with his God, and
the relationship linking men to each other. This is what the scholar Ibn Khaldun
described as: "A divine situation which guides humanity to the choice of
whatever is good for their life and their living." If we look at the origins and
bases of this meaning we find that it is stable and does not undergo change or
accept renovation as it is an external truth.
Second, the state in which man is in his relation with the first meaning intellectually and emotionally as well as in practice and behaviour. It is in this sense that one may be referred to as having a weak religion or having a strong religion, or one whose Islam is perfect or imperfect.
Religion in this situation is changing and mobile, it may increase or decrease, weaken or strengthen, become clear or troubled, straighten or deviate, according to man's understanding of it, his belief in it and his commitment to its instructions. This is the meaning that allows renovation. It is no small wonder that the word "religion" in the Hadith refers to the word "nation" and not God. Renovation refers to the religion of the nation and not to the religion of God Almighty.
The Meaning of Renovation
In this context, I feel that there is no motivation why some scholars should deny the use of the word "renovation" in religion, under the assumption that some deviant individuals might use it in situations that are unacceptable to Islam. We cannot be greater guardians than the one who was appointed by Allah to bring Islam to Humanity. He himself used the word 'renovation' and that has been confirmed by the scholars. Thus, there is no appropriate reason why some Muslim should be afraid to use it. The most important issue for him is to delimit its meaning so that it is not used by every individual or group in whatever way they wish. Thus, what is the meaning of renovation in this context?
In his explanation of Al Jaami' Assaghiir, Al'azizi, quoting Al'alqami explains that renovation is the revival of what may have receded as concerns the application of the instructions given by the Book and the Tradition and advice to apply such instructions (. Volume 1, page 411 of Assiraaj Almuniir by Al'aziizii). He thus makes renovation focus on religious action.
A1 Manaawii explains renovation as showing the difference between tradition and deviance, increasing the use of religious scholarship, glorifying religious scholars, and minimising the promoters of deviance (Fayd Alqadiir, Vol. 2 pp. 281-282.) He thus made renovation focus on scholarship.
In another context, he stated that it is renovation of what has been lost in terms of the laws of jurisprudence, what has disappeared from the significant traditions, and what is implicit in the concrete and abstract sciences .( Fayd AlqadiIr, Vol. I p. 10) This involves both scholarship and action, and indeed absolute renovation concerns both scholarship and action.
I would like to point out in this context a very important meaning of the word renovation. Renovation of something is not the attempt to take it back to its initial and original state, so that in spite of its old age, it appears as if it were new. This would be achieved through the strengthening of what has weakened in it, and the restoration of what has collapsed, and the sewing of what has been torn, so that it takes on again an image as close as possible to its original one. So renovation does not mean the change of the nature of what is old, or its substitution by something else that is newly created. Such is not renovation.
For an illustration, let us take an example from perceptions. If we want to renovate an ancient monument, such a renovation would mean the preservation of its essence, mark and characteristics and all aspects of its distinctive features. Restoration should involve all the effects of ageing. It also involves the improvement of its entrances, and the restoration of the paths and ways leading to it as well as its promotion, etc. Renovation does not mean destroying it and building an enormous and most modern building in its stead.
The same goes for religion, its renovation does not mean to issue a new version of it, but to take it back to its original state as it was during the time of the Prophet, his companions and those who have followed their line.
This return to the original version should not scare us, as it does some people. It is in reality a return to leniency and not to difficulty, a return to good news not bad news, a return to focusing on the important issues and not the details.
He who reads the comments of the Prophet's companions and those who have toed their line will find that they are the most knowledgeable of the spirit and aims of Islam. And these people did not take everything literally and were not unduly formal. They were wholly attached to Allah's laws and at the same time they interpreted these laws with a magnanimous spirit, to show people that Allah established His religion to their benefit. It also shows them that Allah wants them to live in ease and not in difficulty. Their method was like what Imam Ali (GBH) referred to as giving predominance to the middle pattern which can be reached by the one who follows and to which the one who precedes can return.
The key to the renovation of religion is awareness and understanding, and in essential Islamic terms it is jurisprudence. I do not mean by jurisprudence the well-known conventional meaning of the word, i.e. that which concerns knowledge of the minor laws dealing with ablutions, prayers, breastfeeding, marriage and divorce only. Although this is required and commendable, jurisprudence is taken here in the meaning it is given by the Quran and the Prophet as mentioned in Allah Almighty's verse: (We have dtailed Our revelations for a people who have understanding) (Surah 6, Verse 98) And that is exactly what Allah denied the idolaters and other enemies of Islam when He described them as (a folk without intelligence) (. Surah 8, Verse 65). He also described hell dwellers as: (having hearts wherewith they understand not) ( Surah 7, Verse 179). God Almighty also said: "Of every troop of them, a party only should go forth, that they (who are le.ft behind) may gain sound knowledge in religion, and that they may warn their folk when they return to them, so that they may heware" (Surah 9, Verse 122). The Prophet (PBUH) said: "He whom God wants to bless is made knowledgeable in jurisprudence" (Authenticated by the Hadith of Mu'aawiyya.).Jurisprudence as it is known in the Qur'an and the Prophet's tradition covers two scholarly disciplines: knowledge of the universe and knowledge of religion. The first concerns knowledge of the creations of Allah and the second is knowledge of the laws of Allah.
Knowledge of the universe means knowledge of the blessings of Allah to minds and hearts of people, and of his laws which do not change wherever and whoever we are, as that is clear from the glorious verses.
Knowledge of religion refers to that which we acquire after a close study of Islam from its crystal clear sources, so that we have a sound understanding of it. An understanding which is free of all deviation and of the exaggerations of extremists and of all the oversights of the squanderers. In our understanding of Islam, we should be inspired by the guidance of the first generation which was the most understanding of the aims of Islam and the most committed to following and applying its commands. This generation was also aware of the distinctive features of Islam concerning comprehensiveness, moderation and leniency, and distinguishing between important issues and details, between essential and minor laws, between what is stable and permanent and what is flexible and changing. They also distinguished between the ranks and levels of actions in the eye of the law, be they good deeds or sinful ones. The pillars are not like the rest ofthe regulations. The regulations are nlike the obligations and the oblare not like the practices of the Prophet or the fixed voluntary acts of worship, and these latter are not like the commendable acts.
On the other hand, unbelief is not like sins, even if they are major ones, and major sins are not like minor offences. The offences that are considered minor are not like the ambiguous ones, which scholars disagree about. Forbidden acts are not like reprehensible ones, and forbidden reprehensible acts are not the same as unforbidden reprehensible acts. The latter are not necessarily the opposite of the former. These acts are ranked, and each rank has its assigned punishment.
The most foolish and dangerous attitude is to try to blur the differences between these ranks and acts, and to consider them all the same. Putting together what Allah has separated is like separating what Allah has put together. Both attitudes are sinful.
As we are at the dawn of the fifteenth century of the Hegira, we need a large scale intellectual and cultural renovation. A renovation which would bring back to creativity its life and renewed activity. We are referring here to creativity in both its facets: the plausible and selective and the artistic and creative. We need creativity that would find for present-day problems solutions from within Islamic law. It should prescribe medicines for the ills of our societies from the ones provided by Islam itself, not concoct ones from the fabrication of the secular West or from the atheistic East.
This makes it imperative for the scientific institutions which are in charge of these matters to help towards this end, and that it should be open-minded towards the innovative views. The Schools of Law should establish their curricula, books and methods of the study of jurisprudence, its origins and history, especially the study of the Qur'an and the Tradition in light of the scientific comparison, in such a way that they allow the shaping of an independent intellectual mentality, capable of creativity in the productive and selective domains. These schools should also enhance the capabilities of its brighter students and strengthen their commitment to pursue this path.
We should also have an innovation which would allow for Islam to be restated in the language of this epoch, and to address each people with its own language. This re-statement should show greater awareness of the characteristics of the modern world and those of Islam, as well as those of the people. It should also show that we have fathomed the deeper and wider meaning of Allah Almighty's verse "And We never sent a messenger save with the language of his folk, that he might make (the message) clear for them" (Surah 14, Verse 4.).The meaning of the verse is not only that we speak English to the English, or Chinese to the Chinese, but also that we know how to access the hearts and minds of the English and the Chinese. The way of access that may be appropriate for one of them is not necessarily the appropriate one for the other. This means that we need to improve our means and methods of spreading the word of Allah as well as the capabilities of the men who undertake this mission. These improvements should meet the requirements of the modern world, those of Islam, and should be made according to the actions that are made necessary by the acts of others.
Talking to people who have reached the surface of the Moon, cannot be the same as that of people who have been living in caves. To each one of them is a way of speaking, and we have to know each, in order to be able to communicate with each one of them, and to understand them and explain to them.
We should undertake an innovation to revise the fields of the human and social sciences from within a genuine Islamic outlook, which is inspired from the universal philosophy of Islam. This revision should take into consideration the way Islam views religion, life, humanity, society and history and should benefit from all the established schools of thought and from the results of their research and analyses. Nevertheless, it should not be enslaved to a single one of its philosophies or to all of them.
All this means that our universities have to liberate themselves from the noose of imitation of the western thought, be it liberal or marxist. They also have to return to the roots and origins of our glorious heritage, borrowing from it and enriching it or altering it. This would allow the birth of generations of independent thought combining the authenticity of Islam and modern innovation.
This is the responsibility of all universities in the Arab and Islamic countries, but principally that of Islamic universities, such as Al Azhar University, the University of Imam Mohammad Ben Sa'uud, the Islamic World University of Islamabad and others, given their training, affiliation and the calibre of their staff .
Such an innovation would allow the Nation of Islam to achieve excellence in the fields of collective duty, in the cosmic and mathematical sciences and their technological applications in the civil and military fields. This would also allow the Nation of the Surah of Iron to be capable of industrialising iron, and of exploiting its hidden and apparent riches. As a result it will not be dependent upon other countries for food and weapons.
This calls for the revision of the methods, means, objectives and systems of education in accordance with the requirements of the modern world, of Islam and evolution.
If the officials in the United States of America call for the necessity to revise their educational system in order for their country to satisfy the requirements of the epoch, and advance that their nation will be in danger if it does not, then what should we do?
Innovation of Islam is not only intellectual, as it is understood by many when they discuss innovation. These people only think of the innovation of interpretation and the awakening of the Muslim mind to confront the evolution of life.
There is no doubt that intellectual innovation, the rebirth of innovation and the correction of the meanings of concepts come in the forefront of the awaited innovation. There is no doubt also that knowledge precedes action and ideas precede motion.
It is sufficient for us that God Almighty started His Revelation to His Messenger (PBUH) with His verse "Read!", and reading is the key to knowledge, intellect and meditation.
But man does not have a mind only, he has a mind and a heart, a body and a spirit. Thus innovation has to englobe the whole person. That is what Islam has glorified to the greatest extent, and has given to each its share.
The scholars who have undertaken the naming of the innovators in the history of Islam agree that Omar Ben 'AbdulAziz (d. 101 H) is the innovator of the first century in spite of the fact that his reign was short and lasted only thirty months.
The innovation that Omar has undertaken did not reside in the intellectual or scientific aspects, as in the case of the innovation of Ashaafi'i in the second century. It resided in the fields of action and justice, as he disallowed the traditions of injustice, and resuscitated those of justice, removed tyranny, restored rights to their people, denied the requests of the greedy amongst his people. He also spread the atmosphere of worshipping and fearing God, and aspiring to what he has. That is why he was considered the fifth of the guiding Caliphs.
He did all that without any pretension or appearances of boasting, instead he did it to invoke Allah in hope and fear, saying :" Oh, Allah Almighty, Omar does not deserve to receive your grace but your grace is so grand that it is bound to reach Omar".Once, after one of his appreciated stands, a
man said to him: " On behalf of Islam Allah will pay you generously oh Commander
of the Faithful." He said, "So you mean, Allah will pay Islam back for its
generosity to me."
So he gave people their rights and put matters in their
places. It is Islam which made Omar, and not Omar who made Islam.
Innovation of faith
Faith refhere to Islamic faith, and its basis is the oneness of Allah, whhas three principal elements: That we accept nobody but Allah as our God, that we do not assume anybobut Allah as our protector, and that we take only Allah as our judge. This is the meaning of the creed that there is no God but Allah.
After the oneness of Allah comes the second facet of faith, that is belief in the message of the Prophet Mohammed (PBUH), "and that Mohammad is His messenger.He is neither a God, nor the son of a God, nor the Holy Spirit, nor an incarnation of God. He is only the servant of Allah and His messenger. God Revealed His Book to him and he passed on to the people what God Revealed to him. He neither betrayed, nor did he conceal the truth, nor did he speak vainly. "It is naught save an inspiration that is inspired" (Surah 53, Verse 4) .
Among the pillars of the faith that Mohammad (PBUH) received from his God, is belief in the Hereafter and in punishment, and that death is not an end in itself. There is an eternal life after our ephemerous life, when each person is given everything that he has earned and thanked by his good deeds. "And whoso doeth good an atom's weight will see it then, and whoso doeth ill an atom's weight will see it then" (Surah 99, Verses 7-8).
The importance of faith in our life
In the life of Muslims faith is not marginal.
It is the essence of our existence, the secret of our living and the gist of our
message. Without it there is no sense to our life and no reason for our being.
If each personality has a key to it, and if you discover it and use it, you will
be able to discover its hidden contents and unfold the secrets of its
capabilities. The key to man's personality in our religion is faith.
And as it is possible to set a car, a ship or an aeroplane in motion and to set
it forward just by the touch of a key, or the push of a button and to use them
to travel long distances, it is also possible with the effect of faith to move
the emotions of this nation and to use it to make miracles and exploits of
championships which can be related like legends.
Many have struck different strings in order to move this nation, but it has neither moved nor has it responded. They have struck the nationalist string, and the socialist string, the democracy string, but have achieved nothing other than crises and catastrophes.
But when you lead this nation with the Holy Qur'an, you hold it high and the same when you call "Allah is Great" and when you invoke the breeze of paradise. Then you will find that the people respond in millions and are ready to die for the sake of Allah.
This faith which is instilled in the innate character of the nation, and stored in its moral make-up is like a healthy seed in a healthy earth. We must take care of it, raise it, protect it and feed it. We should also covet it and preserve it from any poisonous substances or evil insects in order to allow it to grow, improve and mature so that it gives its fruit with the will of God.
Our need for a faith-based education
That is why we are in need of a sound faith-based education, which fills the hearts with authentic divine values: fear of Allah, hope in Allah, solace in Allah, love of Allah, acceptance of Allah, reliance on Allah, repentance, obedience of His commands, and submission to His judgement and that of His prophet. This is stated in the following verses of the Holy Qur'an: "But nay, by thy Lord, they will not believe (in truth) until they make thee judge of what is in dispute between them and find within themselves no dislike of that which thou decides", and submit with full submission" (Surah 4, Verse 4) "The saying of (all true) believers when they appeal unto Allah and His messenger to judge between them is only that they say: We hear and we obey. And such are the successful" (Surah 24, Verse 51)The elements of this education would be evocation of the meaning of the hereafter and all that concerns it: death, the tomb, resurrection, the day of reckoning, standing for the reckoning, the sheets, the balance, the path, paradise and hell.
In other words, we are in need of a kind of divine, positive and moderate mysticism, which is referred to by other scholars as truth with the Righteous and morality with the Creator and that is what is referred to in Allah Almighty's saying: "Lo! Allah is with those who keep their duty unto Him and those who are doers of good" (Surah 16, Verse 128).This is the essence of the right faith: faith in Allah, and doing good for people. True mysticism is, before all, faith and morality.
Ibn 'Al Qayyim refers to some of the early sufiis in his Madaarij Al Saalikiin (Madaarij Al Saalikiin, Vol. 2 p.307) in his definition of sufism by stating that mysticism is behaviour, and whoever surpasses you in his morality will surpass you in his mysticism.
This is the mysticism that we need: mysticism concerning a Qur'an and Prophet's tradition-based education and behaviour: a mysticism which increases faith, makes for gentler hearts, moves feelings, strengthens will, refines the self, straightens behaviour in light of the Qur'an, the Prophet's tradition and the guidance of the righteous ancestors. That is what we try to preserve and what we advocate. That is also what plays the role of growth which is referred to in the characteristics of the Prophet's message: "He it is Who hath sent among the unlettered ones a messenger of their own, to recite unto them His revelations and to purify them", (Surah 62, Verse 2). That is also the "site of good-deeds" which is mentioned in the well-known Hadith of Gabriel and defined in the Prophet's (PBUH) saying: "Good-doing means that you worship God as if you could see Him, and while you don't see Him, He sees you."If mysticism is taken negatively as it is by someone who said: " Leave creatures to the creator, and leave the reign to the king". This is the attitude of one who wants to annul the advice of good-doing and the reprobation of evil doing, and that is unacceptable. It is said that: "He advocated to the people what he wanted. These are words of truth, which are used to lead to falsehood."
If mysticism means the annihilation of the personality of the disciple before his teacher, as it is stated in what follows: "He who says to his teacher: Why?' cannot succeed" It is also said: "The disciple before the teacher is like the dead at the hand of the dead-cleansing man." This is also unacceptable.
If mysticism means a separation of reality and law, as in the saying of some: "He who looks at people from the point of view of law blames them, he who looks at them with the eye of reality excuses them. That is also unacceptable.
If mysticism is a prophecy and a money-making venture in the name of religion amongst the populace, who are led by legends, and for whom amulets are manufactured. That is also unacceptable and we are not responsible for it.
In conclusion, if mysticism is a concentration of anecdotes in the mind, and of partnership in faith, and deviance in worship, and weaknesses in behaviour, and negative attitudes in comportment, and delinquency in life; then we are the first to oppose it.
Then, the true renovation of religion resides in the call back to Islam as it was revealed in the Holy Qur'an and interpreted in the noble Tradition, and as it was understood by the companions and their followers in good deeds. That is, before it was mixed with external beliefs and weaknesses and with the philosophies of the East and the West. We advocate it in its pure form without any partnership, in its clean form without any external additions, complete without any division, balanced without any exaggeration or oversight, a straight path without deviance "And (He commandeth you, saying): This is my straight path, so follow it. Follow not other ways, lest ye be parted from His way. This hath He ordained for you that ye may ward off (evil) "(Surah 6, Verse 153).Our last prayer is to praise Allah, the Lord of the Worlds.
Innovative Research and Renovation
In the midst of legislative orders and modern necessities
On the subject of interpretation and renovation the Qatari magazine 'Al Ummah' had the following interview with the author of this book:
Q: Interpretation (ijtihad) is part of religion and it is one of its foundations which proves the liveliness of Islam and its capacity to find the adequate solutions to the changing probleof life. What are the historical periods of the movement of 'ijtihad? Has its activity stopped as has been alleged by some at particular periods? Who is responsible for this situation? Is it correct that it is the Ottoman Empire as it has been said?
A: Ijtihad started since the time of the Prophet (PBUH), as it was stated in "the story of the 'Asr prayer in Bani Quraydhah " and in the Hadith of Mu'ad when the Prophet (PBUH) appointed him in Yemen, and asked him:"How do you judge amongst people when you are called upon to do so?". He said "I use the Book of Allah". "What if you cannot?", "Then, I use the Prophet's Tradition". The Prophet said :" What if you cannot?", he responded "Then I use my mind and I do not fail". Then he congratulated him and maintained him in his post. This is a famous Hadith whose authenticity has been recited by many religious leaders, among these are Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn Al Qayyim, Al Dhahbii, and Ibnu Kathir. Many of the Prophet's companions have made independent judgement concerning different issues while they were not in the vicinity of the Prophet (PBUH), and when the Prophet learned about that, he either approved of their judgement or he corrected their errors.
After the Prophet's (PBUH) time, his companions (God Bless them) had to rely on interpretation and faced the changing problems of life in the communities of deep-rooted civilisations which they inherited. They reached Islamic solutions, which they adopted from Islamic texts or from Islam's general guidance. They found in Islam, a solution to every problem, and to each ill a cure.
The independent judgement of the Prophet's (PBUH) companions concerning the events of life and their knowledge of the solutions recommended by the religion of Allah to these events, represents the real and authentic knowledge of Islam, which is characterised by realism, leniency, the consideration of people's interests by Islamic law, without exaggeration in the interpretation of the texts.
When one looks at the knowledge of the guiding Caliphs, or that of Ibn Mas'uud, ibn 'Abbes, or 'Aishah and others (God Bless them all), one will confirm that it is crystal clear that the Prophet's Companions (PBUH) constitute the generation that is the most knowledgeable of the essence of Islam. One example that will best illustrate this is the attitude of Omar and his contemporary scholarly companions, such as Ali and Mu'aad, when he refused to divide Iraq upon the conquerors, considering its four fifths as their booty, as it is clearly stated in the holy verse: "And know that whatever ye take as spoils of war, Lo! A fith thereof is for Allah," ,,( . Surah 8, Verse 41) and decided that the land should remain to serve the interest of the following generations of Islam. He told those who opposed him: "Do you want the last of the people to come to find nothing left for them?" Then Ali and Mu' ad said to him: "Find a solution to suit both the first and the last to come". Upon this, he decided that solidarity between the different generations of the Islamic nation, as well as that of the different countries, is obligatory.
The same attitude is that of Othman(GBH) towards stray camels. In the Hadith it is commanded that any stray camels will be left alone, and he said to whoever asked him about them: "Leave them alone, they have their shoes and their water, they go to the water and feed on the trees, until their owner comes." Thus, during the reign of Abu Bakr and Omar, stray camels were left to themselves moving freely and reproducing, without anybody disturbing them, until their owner finds them. During the time of Othman, he found that people changed and started to catch stray camels, and it became difficult for some of them to return to their owners. Then he decided that for the interest of the people it was time to start to collect these stray animals. So he appointed a shepherd to collect them and identify them. When he does not find their owner, he sells them and keeps the money until the owner comes back.
During the era of Ali (GBH), he established a system that insures people's property when they leave it to a workman for repairs, holding the latter responsible in case the property is lost, in spite of the fact that workmen were generally trustworthy. He said: "That is the only way to correct people ", as he had noticed the change in people's behaviour.
Thus it is clear that the knowledge of the companions resided in the width of its horizons, its realism and leniency while it certainly never lost sight of the foundations.
The disciples and followers of the companions toed the same direction and attitude, especially those who established jurisprudence schools throughout the land, by teaching and advising in the case of novel situations and issues. They faced each event with a Hadith. Within these schools and universities which were established inside some of the important mosques, emerged the most famous Imams, leaders of the rites, each of whom had its followers, such as: Abu Hanifah, Maalik, Al Shaafi'ii, Ahmed, Al Thawrii, Al Awza'ii, Al Tabarii, and Dawuud Al Dhaahiri ...
In the first centuries of Islam, the number of interpreters was larger than could be counted. They had various ways and means of understanding and interpreting the laws, while they agreed that the basic source of Islamic law are the Book and the Tradition. The Book is the foundation and the Tradition is the explanation and the clarification. After that come the secondary sources, which follow suit, such as Al Istihsaan, Al Istislaah Wa Saddu Al Dharaa'i', Ri'aayatu Al'Urf, Shar'u Man Qablanaa, and others about which the scholars have disagreed. Some of them authenticated these sources, others denied them, while others expanded or restricted them.
The important fact is that jurisprudence grew and expanded. The number of real, expected and hypothetical issues became bigger; books were written and its rules were established. The ways of extracting these rules from the foundations of jurisprudence were established. Such a science was invented by Muslims, and nothing like it is found in any other nation. It is considered as one of the prides of the Islamic heritage.
Islamic jurisprudence remains the basis of justice and legal opinion in all the Islamic societies. This remained as such until colonisers invaded Islamic countries, and separated Islamic Law from justice and legislation, except in the narrow domain which they named 'Personal Statute'.
It is important to note that what is usually said, concerning the idea that Islam was impaired directly after the period of the guiding Caliphs, is not true. It is undoubtful that during twelve centuries, Muslims did not have any constitution or law which they followed except from Islamic law, in spite of what might have happened in terms of misunderstanding, or misapplication of its lenient rules.
The closing of the practice of
innovative research
As to the notion of the closing of the
chapter of interpretation, we think that the Ottoman Empire has become a rack,
upon which all errors and slips in all areas are hung by many. In reality, the
domination of tradition, and religious chauvinism, and the waning of expert
interpretation, are issues which arose before the era of the Ottoman Empire.
They have also spread to the different countries of the Arab World to different
degrees, in spite of the fact that there was no period which had no
interpreters. Then we find Imam Al Suyutii (d. 911 H) announcing that he reached
the level of unbounded interpretation, hoping to be the renovator of the ninth
century. He is well -known for his understanding of the Hadith stated in Al
Tajdiid. He also wrote his book Al Raddu'alaa man 'akhlada ila L'ard wa Jahala 'anna
l'ijtthauda fii kulli'ishriin fard.
In the twelfth century, there was the great innovator, the wise man of Islam, Ahmed Ben Abdul Rahiim, alias, Shah Wali Allah Al Dahlawi (d. 1176 H). He is the author of Hujjat Allah Al Baaligha, and other original books. In the thirteenth century, we find in Yemen the expert interpreter, Imam Muhammad Ben Ali Al Shuukaanii (d. 1250 H), and whose interpretation resides in the sections and chapters of his books Naylu L'awtaar, Al Saylu Ljarraar, and Al Daraarii Al Mudiitah, as well as his book of interpretation Al Durar Al Bahiyyah and Irshaad Al Fuhuul ilaa Tahqiiq Al Haqq min 'Ilm Al 'Usuul.
In order for us to be fair to reality and history, we have to state the following: The Ottoman Empire has given much importance to the Holy fighting, more than it did interpretation. Islamic leadership requires both: interpretation, in order to know the true path and the true religion which Allah sent through His Prophet (PBUH), and holy fighting in order to protect and preserve such religion. The scholar of Islam, Ibn Taymiyyah, said: "Religion requires both a guiding book, and winning iron", thus referring to Allah Almighty's holy words: "We verily sent Our messengers with clear proofs, and revealed with them the Scripture and the Balance, that mankind ma y observe right measure; and He revealed iron, wherein is mighty power and many uses for mankind ..." (Surah 57, Verse 25).
QQ: During the Ottoman Empire, more importance was given to iron, i.e. they gave more importance to the military aspects of life than to the intellectual ones, until the overwhelming shock of confronting the rebirth of the west. Some scholars consider that renovation in the contemporary era was started by Jamal El Diin Al Afghaanii, except that his followers gradually started to rely simply on the text, and became closer to tradition, especially Muhammad Rashiid Redaa. So, "is it possible to put these efforts in the right perspective from the point of view of the renovation movement? "
A: This quote shows that its author did not have full awareness of the full meaning of renovation, its extent and its rules. Had he had such knowledge, he would have realised that the process was gradual, and did not relapse as it is claimed. It started with generalities, then continued with improvements, until it reached specialisation. It was not steady at the start, and then began to take control. Sheikh Muhammed Abduh was closer to control in the courts of justice, than his master Al Afghaanii, thanks to the profound culture he acquired in Al Azhar. Sir Muhammad Rashiid Redaa was close to control in the courts of justice, than his master Professor Al Imam, thanks to his wide knowledge of
the books of tradition and heritage. He was also well acquainted with the publications of the Salafi school which was represented by Imam Ibn Taymiyyah and his disciple Ibn Al Qayyim. It is he who started the strong campaigns against inertia and imitation in his valuable magazine Al Manar. He also wrote reformative articles and innovative scientific opinions, during a third of a century or more. The interpretations of Sheikh Rashiid and his innovative opinions spread throughout the Muslim World, and were met with greater acceptance than the innovations of his master, in spite of the fact that they were few. As to the interpretations of Sir Jamal El Diin, we hardly know any precise ones. His personality was that of the revolutionary leader, who awakened the minds, aroused the feelings and triggered ambition and commitment. He did not have the personality of the scholar who is consistently led by sources and rules. So each one follows the path that he was born for.
Some of the views of Sheikh Muhammed Abduh in the interpretation of Qur'an were adopted by others. Some of them are those concerning the story of Adam, his statements about the birds of Babel, and the like. His excuse was that the Western civilisation was in its heyday, and admiration thereof was at its highest. Thus, the rational bias was preponderant; and so were the attempts to bend the text until it fit the new concepts, and the adaptation of the commands of religion to the intellectuals who had a western culture. And all this was done even when it required affectation.
As to those who want to evaluate any person, and to qualify his thought and works, it seems only fair to put the latter in their special historical context, and not to compare his time and space to our own time and space. Some of the views that seem to us today to be clear and obvious, were not so in his time. God bless a man who is fairer to others, and who gives every worker what he deserves and is a fair witness for the sake of God.
Legal interpretation is a collective duty at times and an individual duty at other times. It has its meaning, its extent and its rules. Can these issues be clarified so that confusion does not set in and so that those who are not fit for interpretation, do not undertake it.
Innovation should be construed as making one's utmost effort and pouring one's widest knowledge in the extraction of the legal rules from its proofs through observation and thinking. It is a collective duty that applies to the whole nation. The nation becomes like an orphan if a number of its members do not satisfy its need in innovation. Thus it becomes an individual duty of anybody who feels that he is qualified and has the capability to undertake it, if he does not find anybody to undertake such responsibility in his place.
Innovation is needed in two
situations:
First: The situation in which there is no legal text available, and where
the legislator has deliberately left a gap, out of compassion and not out of
forgetfulness. This allows the innovator to fill the gap in a way that satisfies
the expectations of the people, according to the paths which are followed by
such innovators as analogy, preference or adaptation to the situation, as well
as other reasons.
It is to be noticed that in some areas of jurisprudence there is a proliferation of texts dealing with points of detail sometimes, for example: worship and family issues, which hardly change throughout the ages and places, while there is dire need for texts that forbid disputes, as long as it is possible. Besides, there are areas where the texts are to a large extent scarce, or too general and summarised, thus leaving to people the freedom to innovate by themselves - in light of the overall sources - according to the interests of their society, and the conditions of their era, instead of finding detailed texts that would tie them or restrict their movement. This is exactly the case in the issues of consultation, the ruling system, the proceedings at law, the legal steps, and the like.
Second: The area of hypothetical texts, whether they are hypothetical in their occurrence, and that is the case of most of the Prophet's Hadiths, or hypothetical in
Previous